E-Newsletters

Larkin Hoffman Capitol Watch: State Government Shutdown Looms Bookmark and Share


June 20, 2011
by Government Relations Practice Group

 
 
In the 2011 Special Edition: State Government Shutdown Looms
 
 
 
Editor's Corner
by Peter Coyle
 
The prospect of a shutdown of Minnesota government agencies and services is more likely as July 1st approaches with no state budget resolution in sight.  Negotiations between Governor Mark Dayton and leadership of the Minnesota legislature are occurring, though it is hard to gauge their progress based on the media coverage and the political positioning of the respective camps.  Remarkably, nobody knows for sure what will be the effect of a state government shutdown, which will affect every department, agency and service funded by the state’s biennial budget.
 
This week Minnesota Attorney General Lori Swanson sought a court determination that certain state government functions could continue to operate without an approved budget.  Her Petition painted a picture of criminals being released from jails, sick and disabled patients going untreated, etc. to underscore the need to identify critical functions of state government that, by necessity, cannot be shut down no matter the reason.
 
Our most recent experience with a shutdown of Minnesota government occurred in 2005 as a result of a budget impasse between then-Governor Tim Pawlenty and DFL legislative leadership.  That shutdown lasted approximately one week; a special master was appointed by the courts to review requests for “core function” classification to ensure that tasks deemed “essential” were not halted.  The relatively short duration prevented anything cataclysmic from happening; in fact, most Minnesotans probably did not know there was a shutdown based on their own day-to-day activities.
 
This time, Minnesota businesses may find that necessary licenses and permits, or similar approvals, will be delayed, possibly for an extended period of time.  Any business with a pending application for a permit or license, would be well-advised to pursue issuance of it immediately. 
 
Here is a sample of state government functions likely affected by a shutdown:
  • Drivers license renewals
  • State agency permit and license approvals
  • State court civil proceedings
  • State parks and rest stops
  • Environmental reviews
The actual list of affected functions is substantially longer given the breadth and scope of state government.  Whether anyone notices a shutdown this time depends on its duration.  Secondarily, the resulting budget changes undoubtedly will have long-term effects on those state services that experience the most significant change to their budgets. 
 
Julie Perrus’ article details Governor Dayton’s plan for implementing a shutdown, together with his plan for dealing with essential state government functions.  But even he, as the chief executive of the state, cannot spend money that has not been appropriated by the legislature.  Consequently, notwithstanding any shutdown, some level of court activity will need to function to process requests for “core function” classification.
 
We will keep you updated on the impact of a state government shutdown.  If you have questions about the potential impact of a shutdown on your business or organization, feel free to call one of our government relations attorneys.  We’ll be happy to talk with you.
 
 
 
 
Possible Implications of a State Government Shutdown
by Julie Perrus
Thank you to our summer law clerks, Josh Brekken, Sawan Patel, and Jennifer Singleton, who contributed to this article.
 
There is one thing I know for sure:  If you have camping reservations at a state park over the Fourth of July, you should make other plans.  As a government shutdown on July 1 looms before us, there is little certainty about what services will be deemed “core functions” by the Ramsey County District Court, which is scheduled to hear arguments on the matter on June 23, 2011.  Calls to state agencies last week reflected the confusion.  Many calls went unreturned.  Others stated that they are taking guidance from Governor Dayton’s outline of Critical Services, which was submitted in response to Attorney General Lori Swanson’s Petition of June 13. 
 
The determination of core functions of state government is a balancing act that has been addressed most recently by the court in 2001 and 2005.  In those years, under Governors Ventura and Pawlenty, a failure to resolve the state’s budget by July 1 led to brief government shutdowns.  Concerns that this shutdown may last several weeks, or even several months, makes the determination of core functions even more critical. To read more, click here.
 
 
 
Contact Our Government Relations Attorneys:
Peter J. Coyle
Email 952-896-3214
 
 
Peder A. Larson
Email 952-896-3257
 
Marnie S. Moore
Email 952-896-3377
 
Julie L. Perrus
Email 952-896-3308
 
Gerald L. Seck
Email 952-896-3205
 
 
This alert is provided as a service to our clients and firm associates. While information provided in this publication is believed to be accurate, it is in general nature and should not be construed as legal advice.